Best Pick Up Lines / Cheesy Pick-Up Lines You must be a witch, because this party was normal ten minutes ago and now it's enchanting. You must be a witch, because this party was normal ten minutes ago and now it's enchanting. Appears in Cheesy Pick-Up LinesHalloween Pick Up Lines Previous line Random line Next line More Like This Is it a full moon tonight? Because I've been acting a little wild ever since I saw you. Trick or treat? Actually, don't answer that. You're obviously the treat. Is that a costume, or did you seriously come as the best-looking person at this party? Are you a spider web? Because I walked in here and got completely caught up in you. Are you a cauldron? Because something is definitely brewing between us. Are you a pumpkin spice latte? It's barely October and I'm already obsessed with you. Are you a black cat? Because crossing paths with you is the luckiest thing that's happened all year. Are you a skeleton? Because I've got a bone to pick with how good you look tonight.